I'd call Cloud a hero of Heart for the struggles with a fractured identity. I've only played the original game, so I don't know Zack well, but could be Hope? That one relates heavily to beliefs.
Why didn't I think of Heart that is literally perfect for Cloud thank you! EDIT: Ok, what I have: Sephiroth- Prince of Space Angeal- Knight of Doom Genesis- Seer of Time Zack- Heir of Heart Aerith- Witch of Hope Cloud- Page of Heart Tifa- Maid of Void Barrett- Mage of Blood Yuffie- Thief of Rage (Bonus Cissnei because I love her: Rogue of Light)
a running gag me and my friend have is me assigning bard classes to their favorite characters and then comparing them to cronus. (it's even sparked a snappy catchphrase: all ya faves are bards) on the plus side, it means i've determined that burgerpants from undertale is absolutely a bard of hope, with mettaton being a thief of hope. (so i created a half-joking au where cronus is their lovechild from a one night stand and they fucking hate each other). steven from SU is a heart player but i don't know what class. for PMMM, homura is a witch of time and madoka is a dead ringer for a muse. not sure what aspect though, but i've seen heart and it seems to fit.
FF7 AU where Sephiroth stabbing Aeris just makes her go God Tier and come back to kick his ass. :::PPP
She was surprisingly hard for me- it was either that or Thief of Breath. I settled on Rage because afaik Rage is the aspect of pure little motherfuckerness
Rage is a pretty murky one in exactly what it encompasses, but both that and Breath could make sense with her goal to restore Wutai's power and independence. Steal power/ability to act (in the form of materia) from other people to arm hers.
Slams into thread OKAY UTENA this are rough and this was surprisingly hard Anthy- Witch of Rage Nanami- Page of Rage Miki- Seer of Light Kozue- Mage of Mind Juri- Knight of Heart Touga- Thief of Breath Saionji- Heir of Rage Shiori- Maid of Heart .... Utena- Bard of Hope
...what if I did Zero Escape (uh, some major spoilers below): Spoiler Ace: Bard of Blood Snake: Mage of Mind Santa: Prince of Doom Clover: Witch of Rage Junpei: Maid of Hope Akane: Seer of Time Seven: Knight of Life Lotus: Rogue of Light Ninth Man: Heir of Void (lmao) Sigma: Lord of Space Phi: Rogue of Time Tenmyouji: Maid of Hope Quark: Heir of Hope Clover: Witch of Rage Alice: Mage of Light K: Heir of Heart Luna: Sylph of Blood Dio: Bard of Everything. The Bardiest Bard to ever Bard. Bard of Heart Carlos: Knight of Time Akane: Seer of Mind Junpei: Maid of Hope "Q": Mage of Heart Eric: Heir of Doom Mira: Prince of Blood Diana: Muse of Life Sigma: Lord of Space Phi: Thief of Time Zero: Lord of Mind Doing this made me realise how little characterisation Seven and Lotus get :/ I'm happy with the classes but not so much the aspects.
Spoiler: Steven Universe spoilers Currently considering Prince of Breath for Lapis Destruction through seeking freedom, or a clever reference to her being unable to speak for so long... Or that she drowns her enemies.... eta drowns not spends
I rambled at this to Morven but let's put it here too I guess. Jame is a Prince of Time. Just destruction piled onto more destruction. However she has so much destructive potential she can destroy the very concept of destruction via word play bullshit. Via breaking things she breaks them so hard that they are made fixed again. Because she broke the concept of broken. Tori is a Page of Space. He has the single greatest creative potential out of anyone in that series. He is the avatar of the Creator! But Tori is such a stubborn piece of shit. He just can't accept it, so even though he has so much potential it is going unused. Kindrie is Heir of Blood because I said so.
...I just realized Kelsier from Mistborn probably has the same classpect as Eridan and this is excessively amusing to me.
(I am weeaboo trash let's do the Naruto series XD) Naruto - Heir/Knight of Hope (Or Blood, if we want to go with the 'blood relates to familiar ties and found family' theory) Sasuke - Prince of Rage (I think? I was going to go Void but I think the invisible stats aspect works better for Itachi) Sakura - Sylph of Life Kakashi - fully-realised Page of Space There are others but it's 5am here and I haven't really slept ^^;;;
Okay so I'm slightly more awake now enough to do some more speculation, help me here people - Three Sannin: Jiraya - Rogue of Hope Orochimaru - Thief of Rage (Or Light, but I like the idea of teacher/pupil aspects matching up XD) Tsunade - Bard/Page? of Life Ame Trio: Konan's actually the easiest, because she's clearly a Witch (of Breath? I mean her ultimate battle was to give freedom against 'Tobi', and the Windy Thing would tie in with her paper jutsu.) Yahiko was almost def a Heir - maybe of Light, but inverted? Or Heart?(Because you know, canon happened. Which classpect relates most to self-sacrifice for an ideal that may or may not ever actually happen?) I thought long and hard about Nagato, and my instinct is to say that he's either a Maid or possibly even Muse of Life. (Artifically, I suppose - maybe he was born a Page and was forcibly upgraded by [spoilers?]) Other Uchiha no Plot Devisu: Itachi: I mean he's obviously a Void player what with, well, him, but maybe Rogue or Thief? (Both stole and destroyed Life in order to work from the shadows...) Madara: Lord. Lord lord lord. Of Rage, I think, especially concerning his past and the fact of hatred and rage being born of love. Uchiha don't deal well with strong emotions, it seems. Tobi/ Spoiler Obito : I want to say that maybe he started out a Bard of either Heart or Hope. And that is why you don't dismiss the bard player, people. Any other input?
Some random other Cosmere characters besides Kelsier the Prince of Hope: Vin is an Heir of Doom Elend is a Page of Mind Sazed seems like a Mage but I can't figure out what of Something something Warbreaker Breath jokes Vivenna is a Maid of Rage Surgebinders are cheating because they're already in a personality-based magic system but Kaladin = KNIGHT. KNIGHT KNIGHT KNIGHT KNIGHT KNIGHT. Which is probably appropriate to most Windrunners. (More specifically, Knight of Breath.) My money's on a lot of Truthwatchers being Seers and Edgedancers being Sylphs, though I still don't have that Knights Radiant cheat sheet I desperately want so I can't say for sure. Szeth is a Hero of Doom "Dad" is probably not a valid class but if it was that would be Dalinar's. Dadinar. Dad of Blood.
Haha, I was going to say "I think Renarin's probably a Seer" and then I saw you'd already covered that!
